Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.
Sort By:
Date: Newest to Oldest
Date: Oldest to Newest
Rating: High to Low
Rating: Low to High
Name: A-Z
Name: Z-A
Review Source: A-Z
Review Source: Z-A
Per Page:
10
20
50
100
Beverly Schoen
10/13/2026
5.00
Buying a car from Gary was a refreshing difference from past experiences. He is a truly good, honest man. He helped us all the way with the financing and paperwork. We traveled some distance to Sarasota, and Gary called us later to check that we got home ok You couldn't find a better man to do business with. We, Richard Kelly, highly recommend MGM Motors and Gary if you want a great experience.
Jonathan Allegato
10/09/2026
5.00
I recently bought a 2022 Acura TLX type S from Gary. And I have to say this is the easiest, most transparent, most personal carbine experience I’ve ever had. He was so accommodating and went out of his way to make sure I was comfortable with the purchase even so much as to call me a few days later and ask how satisfied I was if you’re in the market for a car don’t miss out on this. gem of a dealership may not be the biggest, but Man is he the best!!!
Thomas Weigand
10/06/2026
5.00
My boys and I drove down from St. Augustine to pick up our vehicle and Gary made the entire process incredibly easy. He worked with me for about a week beforehand answering all of my questions and addressing any concerns I had along the way.When we arrived, the vehicle was fully detailed, ready to go and exactly as expected. Gary was accommodating, straightforward, quick and efficient throughout the entire process. He does good business and made the trip well worth it. I’d absolutely recommend Gary to anyone looking for a smooth and professional car buying experience. Thanks again, Gary!
Jordan
09/04/2026
5.00
Legitimately a great place to buy a car, I was buying from across the country but MGM had the exact truck I wanted, Gary was very agreeable and helped through the entire process from start to finish. The whole process went smoothly and I could not be happier. Thanks!
Jerrold Kamensky
09/04/2026
5.00
Gary at MGM is, without a doubt, the most honest, reliable, and of the highest integrity of, not only car salesmen, but of any businessman I have ever done business with. I’m 81 yrs old so that’s saying a lot. I purchased a 3 year old Genesis, still under warranty. To me, it appeared clean as a whistle, not clean enough for Gary. He took it back to the dealer. Had them do everything that could be done under warranty, including replacing chrome that had begun to pit. I didn’t ask for that. Gary knows his cars and he saw to it that the car left his shop in the best possible condition at no additional charge to me. No matter what time you are looking for if Gary‘s not selling it, ask him to find it for you.
Rich Daly
08/11/2026
5.00
Gary went above and beyond to get this car for me, he is a true professional.
eric lepley
06/03/2026
5.00
I purchased a gorgeous 22 Genesis G70 3.3T from MGM. Gary was incredibly knowledgeable, helpful and accommodating. He went out of his way to make the purchase experience as smooth as possible. This was honestly the best car buying experience I’ve had to date! I highly recommend you give Gary and MGM Motors a chance!!
Donald Dorion
05/27/2026
5.00
A couple of weeks ago I started shopping around for a Honda Accord hybrid. I came across MGM motors they had one that was in showroom condition with a very low miles for a great price. I really got a great deal saving thousands of dollars. Gary Was great from start to finish. He's honest, transparent, extremely knowledgeable and personable. This was the best experience I ever had buying a car. I do my homework when I buy a car and I can honestly say I saved roughly $10,000. MGM offers a great extended warranty for a very good price from a top notch warranty company.It's a real win-win situation. If MGM has your car I highly recommend you call and visit his lot.
Andrew Adamik
05/18/2026
5.00
This place is fantastic. Gary is extremely knowledgeable with years of experience. I couldn’t be happier with the vehicle I bought from him. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone. Gary is very straight forward which I appreciate very much. For anyone looking to buy a luxury vehicle for a great price/low mileage this is the place to go.
Nicholas Vogelsang
05/16/2026
5.00
Gary is awesome. I’ve never worked with a more honest and wholesome car dealer and I’m not sure one even exists that is as close to his level. Accommodating and a pleasure to do business with.
